Dear Bastian let's fix your blog post.

Philipp thinks, the fact that rng is not using the information in /usr/share/bug renders rng “unfit for release” and upgraded the corresponding bugreport from wishlist to serious. Moreover: since I dared to downgrade the report back to wishlist he decided to remove rng from testing and block it until the bug is fixed.

s/Philipp/the Release Team/g. And yes, we believe that reportbug-ng goes against the Maintainers wishes, and doesn't help users that don't know how to report a bug (and which are rng audience unless I'm mistaken).

I don’t want to heat the debate about this bug again, but Philipp’s decision seems arbitrary for me and I wonder if the same standard is applied to every other Debian package.

It's not, it was discussed in the Release Team and was not Philipp on his own alone. And yes, the same standards of quality is wanted for every package in Debian.

I mean, rng has no release critical defects.

That's you claiming that, there have been really constructive remarks in both bug that we upgraded, and that I think explain wisely why the current reportbug-ng behaviour doesn't makes it a suitable reportbug tool right now. I think for example that Sam's and Michael Biebl contributions in both bugs are good explanations of what is wrong and why.

It just does not use the aforementioned scripts as additional information in bugreports — does this really render the software “unfit for release”?

Yes it does. Again, people that use rng are I think, less experienced users, who need guidance through the bug reporting process. The kind of users that often send annoying bug reports. Instead of lowering the annoyance factor, you aggravate it. In the end, rng makes the frustration higher, and totally fails to meet its primary goals: making bug reporting nicer, simpler, and more efficient for the Reporter and the Maintainer. While it's probably nicer for the reporter, you totally fail on the other part of the contract. And if you don't care about the Maintainer, then well, reportbug-ng is just a spam machine to them, and your careless attitude toward them is “unfit for release” for sure.